• Log in
  • Sign up
  •  
  • About
  • Entrepreneurs
  • Rainmakers
  • 88mph Garage Nairobi
 
HumanIPOHome to African Tech
    
  • News
  • Activity
  • Startups
  • People
  • Investors

Follow African Tech scene

You have successfully subscribed!

Notify me!

Featured news

The HumanIPO Debate: Should CCK continue implementing the reduced MTR rates?Odinga to use AR apps for election campaign

In partnership with:

Most read

  • Safaricom launches paperless, no collateral credit service MShwari

    November 27, 2012

  • Kenyan media network launches road traffic management app

    November 27, 2012

  • Mobile money transfers in Kenya close to country’s national budget

    November 27, 2012

  • Highlights from Mobile Marketing Africa Focus Day at Mobile Web in Africa 2012

    November 28, 2012

  • thumbzup for Absa's "world-first" payment device

    November 29, 2012

  • Kenyans on Twitter mobilise car pooling in the wake of transport hitch

    November 30, 2012

Latest by country

Kenya

  • The HumanIPO Debate: Should CCK continue implementing the reduced MTR rates?

    November 30, 2012

  • Is the ATM’s death due to mobile money?

    November 30, 2012

South Africa

  • Online access to Cape Town’s planning projects launched

    November 30, 2012

  • South Africa’s first legal streaming service surpasses 20 million tracks

    November 30, 2012

Nigeria

  • Shanduka Group acquires stake in MTN Nigeria

    November 30, 2012

  • Gamsole ready to take African gaming global

    November 29, 2012

Follow us!

HumanIPO Twitter feed

Follow entrepreneurs, investors and tech enthusiasts!

Join today!

Latest by category

Startups

  • Johannesburg accelerator chief urges venture capitalists to be more visible

    November 30, 2012

  • Cameroon farmers’ mobile app set to send vital information to thousands

    November 30, 2012

Mobile

  • Nashua and Cell C call for a reduction of termination rates

    November 30, 2012

  • Cameroon farmers’ mobile app set to send vital information to thousands

    November 30, 2012

Internet

  • Online access to Cape Town’s planning projects launched

    November 30, 2012

  • South Africa’s first legal streaming service surpasses 20 million tracks

    November 30, 2012

Telecoms

  • The HumanIPO Debate: Should CCK continue implementing the reduced MTR rates?

    November 30, 2012

  • Is the ATM’s death due to mobile money?

    November 30, 2012

Features

  • The HumanIPO Debate: Should CCK continue implementing the reduced MTR rates?

    November 30, 2012

  • Is the ATM’s death due to mobile money?

    November 30, 2012

Events

  • African Digital journalist projects get US$1M funding

    November 29, 2012

  • GrowthAfrica, Village Capital launch accelerator pitch fest in Nairobi

    November 29, 2012

Social Media

  • South Africa’s first legal streaming service surpasses 20 million tracks

    November 30, 2012

  • Harnessing the benefits of ad targeting for political gains

    November 30, 2012

Gadgets

  • Cosatu is warned by government over planned e-toll protest

    November 30, 2012

  • Microsoft to charge businesses more for services via multiple devices

    November 29, 2012

November 29, 2012 · by Robin Okuthe

The Curious Case of Nyagaka Anyona Ouko, Conclusion - Part IV

Share Tweet
Safaricom’s rejoinder to this HumanIPO series seems to rebuff Ouko’s claims to be the originator of M-Pesa mobile money transfer platform.

 


Safaricom said that whereas Ouko’s story is to all intents and purposes an attractive tale of an enterprising Kenyan youth with a good business head on his shoulders, it is not a story that has any credibility in as far as his claim to being the inventor of M-Pesa is concerned.

The telco’s defensive statement has, however, left many questions hanging, with Ouko defending himself by saying he “did not own the M-Pesa patent because he is not a good IP lawyer.”

The concept of patenting has been in existence since time immemorial. In Kenya, it is contained under the wider concept of Intellectual Property Rights (IPRs). Many critics have concluded that it is vital that Kenya develops “a strong policy framework surrounding intellectual property rights and in this case surrounding patents in order to have control over the application of technology or technological processes”.

In the innovation businesses, the patent holder takes it all


Safaricom claims ownership of the technology’s intellectual property (IP) rights. The company’s director of corporate affairs Nzioka Waita explained to HumanIPO that the intellectual property rights in the Vodafone Money Transfer (VMT) system, which is the core technology platform running the M-Pesa system, belongs to Vodafone.
Some experts have since said that the inventions may either be products or processes that offer a new way of doing something or give a new technical answer to a problem, which in this case makes Ouko’s claims justifiable.

“It was worse still when I started the whole IP process in 2002. I didn’t know any IP lawyer back then. Even the few firms that I talked to and were willing to take up the challenge, were simply too expensive for me. This led me to start seeking advice ad hoc. It was very easy for the idea to be stolen from the word go,” Ouko said.

According to Waita, Safaricom owns the patent, giving it certain rights of protection from having the invention exploited including making, importing, offering for sale, selling and using the product or process (if the invention is a process).

The IP in M-Pesa is in two forms

He said the IP in M-Pesa is in two forms, including  the trademark and the proprietary software design and functionality, adding that the IP in the trade mark M-Pesa is jointly owned by Vodafone and Safaricom in Kenya, while Vodafone owns the trademark outside Kenya.

In response to Safaricom, Ouko said: “You will be surprised that unofficially, I had discussed this idea with some of your staff at Safaricom. It is because I do not have any evidence apart from witnesses that I do not normally talk about it. What I brought was just documentary evidence.”

He explains that he was sent to KECOBO by KIPI way back in 2003, as the former expected him to be aware of what he had to do.

The Industrial Property Act

For a patent application to qualify in Kenya, it must be new, it must involve an inventive step and it must be industrially applicable, according to the Industrial Property Act. According to Ouko, for the idea to be protected it has to be in a form which can be protected and it is always an IP lawyer who can help in that. It should be policy that innovators have access to a publicly available IP lawyer.

Safaricom, however, discounts Ouko’s claims, arguing that even if it were deemed by KIPI to be patentable (which apparently it was not, hence his referral by KIPI to KECOBO), the patentability of his invention would not invalidate the VMT solution or mean that VMT infringed on his invention. Indeed there are other similar platforms the world over such as Obopay, Fundamo or Com Viva.

Ouko said: “Even though I started talking about my idea way back in 2002. I finally received the copyright letter in 2006 and the Certificate in 2012. Safaricom indicates that the first time they talked about the money transfer was in 2003 and filed for the patent in 2006 of which they received a patent in 2007.”


Waita seemed to brush aside Ouko’s argument, saying he was one amongst many Kenyans who used airtime as a cash equivalent.


“By his own admission, his cash transfer system was based on airtime. It did not comprise a ‘wallet’ distinct from the customer’s airtime. Whether that ‘invention’ is patentable or not is debatable. It is also noteworthy that airtime to cash conversion has existed in Kenya from the inception of the prepay voice product,” he said.


Was the idea therefore stolen?


Safaricom’s motives have been questioned by some observers, with some of the opinion that the telco might have hijacked Ouko’s idea, which was at the outset viewed as a “mere business idea”.

According to the Kenya Industrial Property Act 2001, an invention is described as a solution to a specific problem in the field of technology and may relate to a product or a process. Mere presentation of information is, however, not patentable.

Some observers have argued that if Safaricom are aware of this, it would be a surprise if as a giant firm it would fail to pick “a hustler’s idea, use it and just move on.”

Ouko points that the he delivered a letter and proposal to Safaricom about the mobile transfer platform in May 2006 in which Waita challenged him that he would have to demonstrate the novelty of his idea and the inventive step for it to be patentable.

Explaining his ordeal, Ouko said: “In simple terms I lost the patent then simply because I did not have access to a good IP lawyer and I did not have IP law knowledge. However, be sure that did not stop me from bringing over the idea in its crude form. Or maybe it is just because I was in Kenya by then,” he explains.

However, what is disturbing, Ouko says, is that Safaricom Ltd also filed a patent about Mobile money transfer in August 2006.


“Actually, the KIPI officer just looked at it and referred me to KECOBO,” he says, adding, “Secondly the officer I talked to imagined that the whole process of money transfer is a ‘Business Method’ which could not be patented.”


“With that background I will safely tell you that had Safaricom tried to patent the money transfer in Kenya way back in 2006 or even earlier, maybe they might have not managed it. KIPI I must say has also come along way,” he said.


Commenting on this, Ouko said: “It is worth noting that Safaricom never replied to my letter or at any time refer to it.”


On April 25, 2012, Ouko presented another innovation to Safaricom. Unlike in the previous scenario, Safaricom acknowledged receipt of his idea. He says: “Probably as a change from the past, they did acknowledge and I even received an e-mail. I did raise concerns about protection and a possibility of signing a non-disclosure agreement.”


He adds that the officer he spoke to however declined stating that “Safaricom cannot sign documents about issues it did not understand.”


“In fact, the officer even called me and we discussed on phone for some time. He told me to answer a few questions regarding my innovation so that he could decide whether to officially call me for a meeting or not. That was still April 2012. I have not heard from him ever since. I hope I won’t again see the idea floating around thanks to Safaricom,” he said.


He further refutes Waita’s claims as far as the process is concerned, saying the document he deposited with KIPI, or the one I initially sent over to Safaricom, should be revisited as it does have the process.


“Even M-Pesa as done by Safaricom now is not the same as the original one. It has been undergoing lots of changes. Therefore the fact that the original process I sent over is not as robust as M-Pesa you have currently I would say is immaterial,” he says.


On the issue of functionality, Ouko insists that the same document should be revisited as it was made solely by him.


He says the primary reason why he never considered legal redress is because “it costs money to hire competent lawyers.”


A question to Mr. Collymore


“Maybe one last question Mr. Collymore? Why it is that Safaricom is always happy to receive innovations? After which seemingly helpful personnel request for more information and when they have understood the innovations fully you cut all links without even one official reply?” Ouko concluded.

Share Tweet

FB comments

Latest news

  • image
    1 day 13 hours ago

    Online access to Cape Town’s planning projects launched

    A new website launched by the City of Cape Town is aiming to give easier access to all planning and building information.

  • image
    1 day 14 hours ago

    South Africa’s first legal streaming service surpasses 20 million tracks

    Simfy, South Africa’s first legal music streaming service, now has more than 20 million songs on its database.

  • image
    1 day 14 hours ago

    Johannesburg accelerator chief urges venture capitalists to be more visible

    Better education for young innovators and venture capitalists marketing themselves more effectively are the keys to awakening the (more)

  • image
    1 day 16 hours ago

    Nashua and Cell C call for a reduction of termination rates

    Nashua and Cell C agree wholesale mobile termination rates should be reduced in order to promote competition.

  • image
    1 day 16 hours ago

    Datatec acquires Comztek for US$10 million

    ICT solutions group Datatec has announced the acquisition of leading hardware and software distributor Comztek Holdings, in a deal valued (more)

  • image
    1 day 16 hours ago

    Harnessing the benefits of ad targeting for political gains

    Online advertising has become an authoritative auxiliary to TV commercials. Although the lion’s share of political advertising finances (more)

  • image
    1 day 17 hours ago

    The HumanIPO Debate: Should CCK continue implementing the reduced MTR rates?

    The Communications Commission of Kenya (CCK) has finally announced a cut in mobile termination rates (MTR), ending months of uncertainty (more)

  • image
    1 day 17 hours ago

    Is the ATM’s death due to mobile money?

    The African financial system has undergone a period of substantial change, the impact of which continues to transform the way financial (more)

  • image
    1 day 17 hours ago

    Local ownership requirement waived for Airtel Kenya

    Airtel Kenya has received an unlimited waiver to the 20 percent local ownership requirement, as the Kenyan government acknowledges the (more)

  • image
    1 day 18 hours ago

    OPINION: Transport problems call for telecommuting solutions in business

    The public transport problems being experienced in Kenya are likely to cost the economy billions of shillings, as most employees remain at (more)

  • image
    1 day 18 hours ago

    Cameroon farmers’ mobile app set to send vital information to thousands

    A farmer’s son has developed SMS technology inspired by TweetDeck in partnership with Cameroonian agriculture agencies to efficiently (more)

  • image
    1 day 18 hours ago

    MTN SA go commercial with their LTE offering

    MTN South Africa has gone live with the commercial availability of LTE (Long Term Evolution) in Johannesburg, Pretoria and Durban, with no (more)

  • image
    1 day 19 hours ago

    Shanduka Group acquires stake in MTN Nigeria

    South African Black Economic Empowerment (BEE) group the Shanduka Group has acquired a minority stake in MTN Nigeria in a deal worth US$355 (more)

  • image
    1 day 20 hours ago

    Cosatu is warned by government over planned e-toll protest

    The South African government has warned any protester caught vandalising property today (Friday) they will face criminal conviction, as the (more)

  • image
    1 day 20 hours ago

    Mobile phone penetration to surpass 80 percent in Q1 of 2013

    Africa’s mobile penetration will jump to above 80 percent from the current 54 percent by early next year, aided by cheaper call and (more)

  • image
    1 day 20 hours ago

    Mobile phones and social media crucial to travel experience, says study

    88 percent of people take a mobile device capable of 3G or Wi-Fi connectivity on holiday with them, with the same percentage under the age (more)

  • image
    1 day 21 hours ago

    Kenyans on Twitter mobilise car pooling in the wake of transport hitch

    Stranded Kenyans are this morning using Twitter to carpool their way to various destinations in the wake of the transport strike across the (more)

  • image
    1 day 21 hours ago

    Talks begin to bring Start-Up Chile model to South Africa

    The Western Cape Government is “seriously interested” in investing in international start-ups to entice them to base, register and grow (more)

  • 1 day 21 hours ago

    Kenya opposes internet regulation by ITU

    Kenya will not back a proposed changes to the Melbourne Internet rules and economic model by the International Telecommunication Union (more)

  • 1 day 22 hours ago

    Further boost for ZA Central Registry for its .africa bid

    South Africa based ZA Central Registry (ZACR) have received a further boost in the race to win the rights to administer the .africa generic (more)

  • 1 day 23 hours ago

    Online trading platform B&S Media making ground in Kenya

    As e-commerce seeks to gain footing in Africa, Kenyan firm B & S Media seems to be accelerating the process by offering a platform to (more)

  • 2 days ago

    ITU hits back at accusations it aims to “restrict” free speech

    United Nations agency the International Telecommunications Union (ITU) has adopted a resolution asking Member States to refrain from taking (more)

  • 2 days ago

    Odinga to use AR apps for election campaign

    Kenyan presidential hopeful Raila Odinga is launching an augmented reality (AR) application to further his election campaign, allowing (more)

  • image
    2 days ago

    Manyatta Rent geared to change face of Kenya’s real estate industry

    The developers of Manyatta Rent, software enabling real estate agents to receive rent via mobile money transfer services, have vowed to (more)

  • 2 days ago

    South African internet users log on mostly for social networking

    Most South African Internet users log on to access social media, with rapid growth in the number of people using their mobile phones for (more)

  • 2 days ago

    ICASA reports to Government on digital migration, but still no deadline

    The Independent Communications Authority of South Africa (ICASA) has still not set itself a new target for the switchover from analogue to (more)

  • image
    2 days ago

    Gamsole ready to take African gaming global

    Nigerian gaming company Gamsole has become the newest entrant into an industry that is slowly taking shape, with companies such as Maliyo (more)

  • 2 days ago

    Microsoft to charge businesses more for services via multiple devices

    A new move by Microsoft means that businesses looking to give their workers access to systems through multiple devices will from December 1 (more)

  • 2 days ago

    New DStv recording service with increased capacity to be released

    Digital Satellite Television (DStv) is improving its personal video recorder (PVR) service giving to give subscribers more storage space (more)

  • 2 days ago

    3 months after launch, Mdundo closes lucrative deals

    Mdundo.com, the first Kenyan startup to sell local music on scratch cards, has sealed lucrative deals with some of the world’s leading (more)

  • 2 days ago

    Safaricom to remain unscathed despite lower MTR

    Barely a week since Kenya’s telecommunications industry regulator lowered the mobile termination rates (MTR), sources from Safaricom (more)

  • image
    2 days ago

    thumbzup for Absa's "world-first" payment device

    A world-first payment device for small businesses has been launched by South African bank Absa in Johannesburg today (Thursday).

  • image
    2 days ago

    African Digital journalist projects get US$1M funding

    As part of the African News Innovation Challenge (ANIC), 20 digital journalism projects have earned US$1 million funding and technical (more)

  • 2 days ago

    Nigerian cybercrime bill passed for second reading

    Nigeria has moved one step closer to passing its cybercrimes bill, as the number of such offences committed continues to rise.

  • 2 days ago

    Last chance for African entrepreneurs to win US$100,000 investment backed by UN

    The deadline for applications to a competition led by the United Nations which will award US$150,000 in investment to African entrepreneurs (more)

  • 2 days ago

    Microsoft aids SMEs with new initiative

    Microsoft hope to provide support, benefits and tools for small and medium scale businesses (SMEs) in the Middle East and Africa in an (more)

  • 2 days ago

    Safaricom and Britam launch new insurance product via M-Pesa

    Safaricom, Britam and Changamka Health have unveiled Linda Jamii, a new insurance facility that enables low income earners to make (more)

  • 2 days ago

    Microsoft enters growing augmented reality market

    Microsoft has been granted a patent for augmented reality (AR) glasses, joining rivals vying to dominate the emerging AR market.

  • 2 days ago

    Liberia’s Cellcom rewards subscribers with 100 motorbikes, provides protective jumpsuits

    Liberia's National Excellence Award winning telecommunications company, Cellcom, is to give away a motorbike to a customer each day for 100 (more)

  • image
    2 days ago

    OPINION: Is Apple looking to cash in on SA textbook shortage?

    In response to widely publicised textbook shortages across South Africa, the country has seen a surge in private organisations trying to (more)

  • 2 days ago

    Safaricom’s MShwari doesn’t threaten M-pepea's emergency micro-credit facility, founder

    Two developers have created ‘M-pepea,’ an emergency micro credit solution accessible via mobile phones, and insist that they are not (more)

  • image
    2 days ago

    GrowthAfrica, Village Capital launch accelerator pitch fest in Nairobi

    GrowthAfrica, under its chief brands The GrowthHub and Village Capital, will today debut Pitch Fest Day in Kenya’s capital Nairobi, an (more)

  • 3 days ago

    Battle between smartphone giants and their patents resurface

    Nokia has filed lawsuits against Blackberry-maker RIM in three countries as the smartphone patent wars erupt again, with Ericsson having (more)

  • 3 days ago

    Vodacom launches M2M management platform for businesses

    South African telecom Vodacom is launching a new M2M management platform, known as a Global Data Service Platform (GDSP), catering to the (more)

  • 3 days ago

    Online permit system introduced for small and “informal” traders in Cape Town

    The City of Cape Town is attempting to cut the red tape “burden” on small traders by expanding its online permit system.

  • 3 days ago

    SA firm uses QR codes for ‘digital memoralisation’

    A South African startup is integrating Quick Response (QR) code technology into places of remembrance, allowing those with Internet-capable (more)

  • 3 days ago

    E-tolling and highway upgrades at the expense of Gauteng motorists

    South Africa’s High Court has heard “tolling can’t be undone” from a lawyer representing the South African National Roads Agency (more)

  • 3 days ago

    Nashua Mobile and Wireless G’s “uncapped” WiFi capped at 3GB, customers will be “throttled”

    South African mobile users are being offered “uncapped” Wi-Fi access for R39 (US$4.50) a month, but the providers have admitted users (more)

  • image
    3 days ago

    How to have your tweet regularly retweeted

    For Twitter users, having a tweet retweeted several times seems a mark of accomplishment, like having your advice passed along by (more)

  •  Like us on Facebook
  •  Follow on Twitter
  •  Youtube
  • News
  • Startups
  • People
  • Investors
  • News RSS
  • About
  • Entrepreneurs
  • Rainmaker
  • 88mph Garage Nairobi
  • In press
  • Logo & brand
  • Feedback
  • Terms and conditions
  • Privacy policy